Cloudera Docs

Comprehensive guide to migrating legacy systems to Snowflake with Cloudera Octopai Data Lineage

Learn about best practices for migrating data from Oracle, SQL Server, and Teradata to Snowflake with Cloudera Octopai Data Lineage.

Introduction

Data migration is a critical part of digital transformation and system upgrades, and it involves transferring data from one system to another. This guide focuses on the migration from Oracle, SQL Server, and Teradata, leading relational database management systems, to Snowflake, a cloud-based data warehousing platform designed for the cloud. It provides a detailed roadmap for a successful data assets migration, including key considerations, challenges, and best practices.

Conducting a comprehensive assessment of the legacy environment, choosing the right migration approach, optimizing data for Snowflake, using the native services of Snowflake, implementing data security and compliance, minimizing downtime and disruption, training the team, and monitoring and optimizing the Snowflake environment after migration are recommended best practices.

Additionally, data and IT teams will need to understand and prepare for differences in how each platform handles things like data types, partitioning, indexing, and cost management to ensure a smooth migration and efficient use of the new system.

Cloudera Octopai Data Lineage plays an integral role in enabling organizations to overcome technical challenges and maximize the value of their data migration from Oracle, SQL Server, and Teradata to Snowflake. Its capabilities are designed to ensure risk mitigation, cost reduction, and efficiency in man hours, thereby contributing to an overall smoother, more cost-effective, and risk-averse data migration process. Cloudera Octopai Data Discovery tool, for example, automates the process of scanning legacy systems to identify existing data assets, their location, format, and business relevance.

The value proposition of cloud migration

Transitioning from on-premise solutions to cloud-based platforms brings a host of benefits, including cost savings, scalability, increased collaboration, and access to advanced analytics and machine learning capabilities. The move also presents opportunities to adopt new methodologies like DevOps and Agile practices, promoting innovation and reducing time-to-market. However, this transition also has significant implications for Data and IT teams, as they need to manage the shift in technologies, adopt new skill sets, and adjust to different operational practices.

Why Snowflake?

Migration from On-Premise Systems

  • Many organizations are moving from traditional on-premise data warehouses to cloud-based solutions like Snowflake. This is due to the scalability, flexibility, and cost-effectiveness of cloud solutions. Common on-premise systems that are often migrated include Oracle, Teradata, and IBM DB2.

Migration from Other Cloud Providers:

  • Some organizations are migrating from other cloud data warehouses to Snowflake. This could be due to a variety of reasons, including better performance, cost, or features offered by Snowflake. Common cloud systems that are often migrated include Amazon Redshift, Google BigQuery, and Microsoft Azure SQL Data Warehouse.

Consolidation of Disparate Systems:

  • Organizations with data spread across multiple systems (both on-premise and cloud) might choose to migrate to Snowflake to consolidate their data into a single, unified platform. This can simplify data management and improve the ability to derive insights from the data.

Unique aspects of Oracle, SQL Server, Teradata and Snowflake

When discussing the migration from Oracle, SQL Server, and Teradata to Snowflake, you must understand the unique aspects of both platforms that might affect the migration process. The systems have the following key characteristics:
  • Oracle, SQL Server, Teradata
    • Mature and Robust

      These systems have been around for a long time, and they are known for their robustness and stability. They have a range of features built over time that can handle complex queries and large volumes of data.

    • Scripting

      These systems have their own scripting utilities that allow users to submit SQL commands in batch mode. They are highly versatile and can be used for importing and exporting data, as well as controlling database workflows.

    • Stored Procedures

      These systems support complex stored procedures. This feature might require significant effort to migrate, as the Snowflake scripting and stored procedure capabilities differ.

    • Data Loading and Extraction

      These systems have powerful utilities for data loading and extraction, which might have been used heavily in data and IT teams current setup.

  • Snowflake
    • Serverless and Fully Managed

      Snowflake is a serverless, highly scalable, and cost-effective cloud data warehouse. It takes away the hassle of managing infrastructure, allowing organizations to focus more on data analysis.

    • Automatic Scaling

      Snowflake automatically scales up and down based on the workload, which means data and IT teams do not need to worry about capacity planning.

    • Real-Time Analysis

      Snowflake allows for real-time analytics on massive streaming data, which is not typically a strength of traditional databases.

    • Integrated with Cloud Platforms

      Snowflake is well-integrated with other cloud services, making it easy to connect with data storage, machine learning, and data processing tools.

    • Data Transfer Service (DTS)

      Snowflake offers DTS for automating data movement from multiple online and offline sources.

    • Security

      Snowflake provides robust security measures, including encryption at rest and in transit, identity and access management, and support for VPC Service Controls.

Migration considerations

Oracle Database

Oracle is a widely used traditional relational database management system. Many businesses are migrating from Oracle to Snowflake due to Snowflake's scalability, flexibility, and cost-effectiveness. The migration process typically involves data extraction from Oracle, data cleaning and transformation, and then loading the data into Snowflake.

Microsoft SQL Server

Another common source for migration is Microsoft SQL Server. This is due to the fact that while SQL Server is powerful and widely used, it can be expensive and lacks the flexibility and scalability that a cloud-native solution like Snowflake offers. The migration process is similar to Oracle, involving extraction, transformation, and loading (ETL).

Teradata

Teradata is a popular data warehouse solution, but many businesses are moving to Snowflake for its superior cloud capabilities, scalability, and cost-effectiveness. The migration process from Teradata to Snowflake involves a similar ETL process, but with additional considerations for the Teradata unique architecture and features.

Migrating from Teradata to Snowflake

Teradata, a popular legacy system, has its own unique challenges when migrating to Snowflake. The process involves understanding the differences between Teradata and Snowflake, such as the handling of NULLs, data types, and stored procedures.

  • Data Types: Teradata and Snowflake have different data types. For example, the Teradata TIME data type does not have a direct equivalent in Snowflake. During migration, you must map Teradata data types to their Snowflake equivalents.
  • Stored Procedures: The Teradata stored procedures use a different syntax than the Snowflake stored procedures. You must rewrite these procedures in JavaScript, which is the language Snowflake uses for stored procedures.
  • NULL Handling: Teradata and Snowflake handle NULLs differently. In Teradata, a comparison with NULL is UNKNOWN, while in Snowflake, it is NULL. You must account for this difference during migration.

Migrating from Oracle and SQL Server to Snowflake

The following considerations apply for migrating from Oracle and SQL Server to Snowflake:

  • Data Types: Both Oracle and SQL Server have unique data types that need to be mapped to Snowflake equivalents during migration.
  • Stored Procedures: Oracle uses PL/SQL for stored procedures, while SQL Server uses T-SQL. These must be rewritten in JavaScript for Snowflake.
  • Indexes: Unlike Oracle and SQL Server, Snowflake does not use indexes. You must rethink any optimization based on indexes for Snowflake.
  • Sequences: Oracle and SQL Server handle sequences differently than Snowflake. If your legacy system uses sequences, you must recreate them in Snowflake.

Potential technical and business challenges

In general, migrating from an on-premises solution to a cloud-based one presents a variety of challenges that need to be carefully considered and managed. Migration from Oracle, SQL Server, and Teradata to Snowflake can pose both technical and business challenges, including schema migration, stored procedures conversion, standard and complex views adaptation, handling of scripts, performance considerations and complex risk management.

In some cases, it might be determined that certain tables from the legacy systems are no longer needed, even before the migration, or for example, that specific ETL processes loading data into these tables might be retired. After the migration, it is crucial to review the entire project, looking for opportunities to reduce maintenance, CPU, storage, people resources, and time.

With the right approach and the use of Cloudera Octopai platform that supports Cross Systems, Inner Systems, and End-to-End Column Lineage for both the legacy systems and Snowflake, data and IT teams can ensure a smooth and efficient migration, leading to better data management and utilization in the long run.

The following technical and business challenges can arise:
  • Technical challenges
    Technical challenges can range from system compatibility issues, data conversion challenges, or issues with connectivity and access rights. They will arise due to differences in data types and SQL dialects, absence of traditional stored procedure support in Snowflake, differences in view handling, managing large files, and distinct performance characteristics of the legacy systems and Snowflake. Consider the following potential technical challenges:
    • Schema Migration: The legacy systems and Snowflake have different data types and SQL dialects. This means that some data transformations might be necessary to convert legacy data types to Snowflake compatible ones. You might need to rewrite SQL queries due to these syntactical differences.
    • Views: In the legacy systems, views are used extensively for data abstraction, simplifying queries, and controlling access. The concept of views exists in Snowflake as well, but the behavior might be different. For instance, the Snowflake views are logical views, not materialized. That means they compute the data when queried, which might affect the performance if not managed properly.
    • Scripting and Stored Procedures: The legacy systems scripts and stored procedures might not be directly compatible with Snowflake, requiring rewriting and transformation. For example, you must consider how to transform the legacy scripts and stored procedures into Snowflake compatible SQL scripts or Cloud Functions, or how to replace the legacy utilities with Snowflake Data Transfer Service.
    • Performance and Data Transfer Considerations: The performance characteristics of the legacy systems and Snowflake can be quite different due to the underlying architecture differences. Snowflake is a serverless, highly scalable, and cost-effective multi-cloud data warehouse designed for business agility, while the legacy systems are popular relational database management systems. Therefore, optimizing for performance might require different strategies in Snowflake as compared to the legacy systems. Moving large amounts of data from one platform to another can be time-consuming and risk-prone. There is a risk of data loss, corruption, or security breaches during the migration process.
    • Utilizing Legacy Utilities: If you are used to the legacy utilities, you will need to figure out how to accomplish these tasks with the Snowflake tools.
  • Business challenges
    Business challenges can include risk management, cost considerations, training and change management. For instance, there might be costs associated with potential downtime during the migration, training for staff to use the new system, and potential resistance from users who are comfortable with the legacy system. Consider the following potential business challenges:
    • Risk Management: Data migration always carries risk. These can include data loss, corruption, or breaches of security. You must have robust risk management strategies in place to mitigate these risks. This includes thorough testing, backup and recovery plans, and security measures.
    • Cost Considerations: While moving to a cloud-based solution like Snowflake can lead to cost savings in the long run, the migration process itself can be costly. This includes the cost of the migration tools and services, potential downtime during the migration, and the cost of training staff to use the new system.
    • Training and Change Management: Moving to a new system requires users to learn new tools and adapt to new workflows. This can lead to resistance, especially if users were comfortable with the legacy system. You must have a strong change management strategy in place to support users through this transition.
    • Performance Tuning: After migrating, data and IT teams might need to spend time optimizing query performance and cost in Snowflake. This can be a complex task and might require a deep understanding of how Snowflake processes queries.
    • Continuing to Monitor and Optimize: Once you migrated to Snowflake, you must continually monitor your system to ensure that it works effectively and adjust as needed.

Migration process overview and best practices

When migrating to Snowflake, you must follow a structured workflow that includes setting up and configuring data transfer, choosing the right extraction method, and identifying and customizing schema. These are key components of the migration workflow.

The migration process can be broken down into seven distinct phases: data discovery, dependencies and scoping for effort assessment, data cleansing and deprecation to migrate the right data, prioritization according to critical paths, selective migration, data conversion, documentation to capture knowledge, and post migration for onboarding and monitoring.

Assessment - data discovery and scoping

Understanding the existing data landscape is the first step - identifying existing data, its location, format, and business relevance. This phase forms the foundation for all subsequent steps, establishing a comprehensive inventory of data assets and their dependencies, which is critical for determining what data to migrate and how.

Cloudera Octopai Data Discovery will automatically scan your legacy system (Teradata, Oracle, or SQL Server), identify data entities, their relationships, and how they are used. By gathering insights about your data assets, data and IT teams gain a comprehensive view of what is in your system, guiding data teams to build a solid migration plan.

Data cleansing and deprecation

Once the data assets have been scoped, the next step is to cleanse the data in the legacy system. This involves removing redundant, irrelevant, or erroneous data to avoid migrating garbage. This step is also an opportune moment to deprecate unused or unnecessary reports fed by the legacy system. This prevents the migration of garbage, and presents an opportunity to deprecate duplicates, redundant or unused assets.

The Cloudera Octopai cross systems lineage and inner-system lineage tools play a crucial role in this phase. By visualizing the data lineage, Cloudera Octopai pinpoints data assets that are no longer being used and can be deprecated, streamlining the migration process and avoiding the migration of unnecessary data.

Prioritization

Selective migration is the best approach for prioritization of the most critical data assets to be migrated first. This can help minimize downtime and disruptions to key business operations. However, it can also introduce the challenge of double maintenance - managing both the legacy and new systems concurrently, which can put additional stress on IT and data teams.

For prioritizing and selecting data, the best approach is to migrate the most accessed tables or those critical to business operations first. The prioritization can be based on the data's business impact, data quality, or compliance needs.

The Cloudera Octopai Data Lineage and Catalog capabilities empower the data team to analyze table dependencies, allowing them to collaborate with the business stakeholders and tag critical accounting data assets within the Cloudera Octopai Data Catalog for prioritized migration.

Data conversion

In this phase, the selected data is converted and transformed to suit the schema, stored procedures, and views of the Snowflake system. Data conversion involves converting legacy-specific SQL code into Snowflake standard SQL. For example, the legacy system TIMESTAMP might need to be converted to the Snowflake TIMESTAMP, and similar conversions for other data types. You must consider stored procedures as well since legacy procedures might not work directly in Snowflake due to syntactical differences.

During the data conversion phase, Cloudera Octopai Live lineage functionality proves invaluable in simulating the effects of transformations, allowing for a comprehensive understanding of potential issues and their impact on data lineage. With Cloudera Octopai, the data team can simulate the conversion of legacy-specific SQL code into the Snowflake standard SQL, identifying any syntactical differences or required data type conversions. By testing and verifying the simulated data lineage, the team can confidently address errors, make necessary fixes, and ensure the accuracy and integrity of the data throughout the migration process.

Post-migration challenges and optimization

After the migration, you must review the entire project, looking for opportunities to reduce maintenance, CPU, storage, people resources, and time. Post-migration, regular monitoring is crucial. For example, data teams might set up a daily check of failed SQL jobs in Snowflake. If data and IT teams see a recurring failure, data and IT teams can then dig deeper to understand the issue that can be a data type mismatch, or syntax error, and address the root cause.

Additional considerations exist for adopting new practices and terminologies related to cloud technologies. You must consider the following key points:

  • Cloud Terminology: Familiarize yourself with the terminology used in cloud computing and specifically in Snowflake. This includes terms like warehouses, databases, schemas, tables, and more. Understanding these terms will help you navigate and manage your cloud environment effectively.
  • Cloud Data Management: Cloud-based data management introduces new practices and tools. You must understand how data is stored, processed, and managed in Snowflake. This includes concepts like data partitioning, clustering, and more. Learn about best practices for optimizing data storage, query performance, and cost management in Snowflake.
  • Security and Compliance: Cloud environments have their unique security and compliance considerations. Familiarize yourself with the security features and options provided by Snowflake. Implement proper access controls, encryption, and data governance practices. Ensure compliance with relevant regulations and standards that apply to your data.
  • Automation and Orchestration: Cloud platforms offer automation and orchestration capabilities that can streamline data pipelines and processes. Explore tools to automate data transformations, workflows, and data integration tasks. Leverage these tools to optimize your data pipelines in the cloud.
  • Scalability and Elasticity: Cloud-based systems provide scalability and elasticity, allowing you to scale your resources up or down based on demand. Understand how to leverage the Snowflake auto-scaling capabilities to handle varying workloads efficiently. Design your data pipelines and infrastructure to take advantage of the cloud scalability benefits.
  • Data Cataloguing and Documentation: Ensure that you create a comprehensive data catalog in Snowflake that accurately documents your data assets, including metadata, data lineage, and business descriptions. This will help users find and understand the data in the new system.
  • Continuous Learning and Training: Cloud technologies and best practices evolve rapidly. Encourage continuous learning and training for your data and IT teams to stay updated with the latest advancements in Snowflake and cloud computing. Leverage training resources, online documentation, and community forums provided by Snowflake to enhance your knowledge and skills.

Efficient migration to Snowflake with Cloudera Octopai

Cloudera Octopai is a valuable solution that empowers businesses during the migration from legacy systems to Snowflake. It automates data discovery, streamlining the migration process and ensuring a smooth transition. With the Cloudera Octopai lineage and impact analysis capabilities, businesses can enhance data management, validate data integrity, and improve overall reliability. Cloudera Octopai also reduces the time and effort required for identifying and migrating relevant data assets. It optimizes resource allocation by identifying and deprecating unused data, while ensuring data security and compliance through robust lineage tracking. By minimizing downtime and disruptions, Cloudera Octopai facilitates uninterrupted business operations during the migration. Overall, Cloudera Octopai delivers significant benefits, making the migration to Snowflake efficient and successful.

Conclusion

Migrating from Oracle, SQL Server, and Teradata to Snowflake is a significant undertaking that requires careful planning, execution, and monitoring. However, with the right approach and tools, it can be a smooth and efficient process that results in significant benefits for your organization. By following the best practices outlined in this guide and leveraging the capabilities of Cloudera Octopai, you can ensure a successful migration that enhances your organization's data management capabilities and positions you for success in the era of cloud computing.